Combustion in the ash pan. The test demonstrated that all of the toilets apart from the test winner start combustion even if the hatch to the combustion chamber is not fully closed. Photo: Anna Sigge

The wrong toilet in a holiday home increases heating costs

An incinerating toilet does not require access to water or sewerage, and avoids the unpleasant job of emptying a latrine. But there are substantial differences in performance, safety and energy consumption – on a cold winter day, one flush can suck out all the warmth from a holiday home, as was demonstrated in Testfakta Research’s laboratory test of five models available on the Nordic market.

Electric incinerating toilets are becoming increasingly popular in properties which do not have running water and sewerage systems. Instead of flushing the waste into the sewer, urine, faeces and toilet paper are collected in a container and burned at high temperature so that only a small quantity of ash remains.

The incineration process involves heating the waste to a temperature of 500–600 °C. The air supply required for combustion is drawn either from the room or from outside the building, depending on how the toilet is designed. The combustion gases are vented through a flue and the ash after incineration is collected in an ash pan in the body of the toilet.

If everything works as it should, only a small quantity of ash remains after the toilet visit, and the ash pan will probably not need to be emptied more than once a week.

But how well do the various toilets function? To find this out, Testfakta Research, on the instructions of Cinderella Eco Solutions, carried out a comprehensive laboratory test of all the incinerating toilets sold on the Nordic market.

thumbnail of Grafik_Forbranningstoalett_UK(180225)

The laboratory test was carried out by RISE (Research Institutes of Sweden), which investigated electrical and functional safety, capacity, energy consumption and how easy the toilets are to install and use. And it emerged that there are major differences between the various toilets, particularly in relation to incineration capacity and safety criticisms. By no means all models can successfully incinerate and evaporate faeces and urine if several people go to the toilet one after the other. Two of the toilets, the Incinolet and the Sunwind, left almost 50 percent of the faeces unburned.

When the laboratory investigated safety, serious criticisms were made of several models both in relation to electrical safety and safety in use. With all the toilets except one, it is, for example, possible to start combustion even if the ash pan is not in place, which involves a risk of damage to underlying material and, in the worst case, fire. On several models, the user is at risk of touching electrically live components, and the majority of the toilets start the combustion process even if the hatch to the combustion chamber is not fully closed.

“It should not be possible to start combustion without all parts of the toilet being in place and in the correct position. Nor should it be possible to come in contact with electrically live components while carrying out tasks such as cleaning the space for the ash pan. There is more to do on this with several of the products,” says Test Leader Lennart Gustavsson at RISE.

The capacity of the toilets was tested in three steps, with one, three and six flushes. For each flush, 150 grams of synthetic faeces, 250 grams of synthetic urine and 10 grams of toilet paper were added.

forbr.toalett_test4

Each incinerating toilet was repeatedly filled with the same quantities of synthetic urine and faeces to test how well each model successfully handles toilet visits. Photo: Anna Sigge

Only three toilets successfully managed full incineration with three and six flushes, the Cinderella Comfort, the Separett Flame and the Separett Cindy. After six toilet visits, two of the toilets, the Incinolet and the Sunwind, left almost 50 percent of the faeces unburned.

forbr.toalett_test11

The ash pan was weighed after incineration to measure the weight in grams of ash or unburned residue which remains after incineration. Photo: Anna Sigge

For efficient incineration, the toilets must have access to an adequate supply of air. During the incineration of a single flush, for example, the Incinolet and the Sunwind draw in a full 157 m3 of air, which is equivalent to the volume of a cottage of around 50 m2. In other words, good ventilation is required to enable the toilet to function efficiently. During the winter, the toilets which take air from inside the room have a significant impact on the indoor climate, since they suck out heated indoor air.
The Cinderella Comfort differs from the other toilets in that it takes air from outside rather than inside the home, so it does not have the same impact on the indoor climate.

”Where toilets take air from inside the home, energy is required to heat up the replacement air. Heating 100 m3 of air on a cold winter day from, say, -10°C to +15°C, takes approximately 0.8 kWh of electricity. This should be added to the energy consumption of the four products which take air from the room,” according to Test Leader Lennart Gustavsson at RISE.

The Cinderella Comfort was the clear test winner, with the highest capacity, the lowest energy consumption and no serious safety criticisms.

 

Testfakta Research, February 2018

Read more here:'Facts about the test'

Facts about the test

Testfakta Research, on the instructions of Cinderella Eco Solution AS, carried out a comparison laboratory test of electric incinerating toilets. The laboratory tests were performed by RISE (Research Institutes of Sweden) Built Environment Division, Energy and Circular Economy Department.

To read more about how the laboratory test was performed and how the results were evaluated, please click here.

 

 

What is an electric incinerating toilet?

An electric incinerating toilet is a toilet in which urine, faeces and toilet paper are incinerated at high temperature. The incineration process heats the waste to a temperature of 500 – 600 °C. The gases produced are vented through a flue pipe. The oxygen supply for combustion is taken either from the indoor space or direct from outside. A fan is fitted to the toilets to ensure that the flue gases are vented. After the incineration process, the ashes are collected in an incineration chamber (ash pan). Incineration is efficient, and the quantity of ash produced is limited, which means that it will probably not be necessary to empty the ash pan more than once a week in normal use.

 

 

Some things to think about before you buy

Before you buy an incinerating toilet, it is a good idea to think about the level of service you can expect from each make – just in case something goes wrong with the toilet.

There is a massive difference in the number of service centres and where they are located between the different manufacturers. It might be necessary for you to dismantle your toilet and drive a really long distance to the closest service partner.

 

Differences in the coverage and length of the guarantee

The guarantees that manufacturers provide for incinerating toilets vary in length, and it is really worth reading the small print.

Separett’s three-year guarantee does not cover ”normal wear and tear, corrosion or defects in the surface”, and some components have a one-year guarantee. Fritidstoa’s three-year guarantee, however, applies to the whole toilet. The five-year guarantees provided by Sunwind and Incinolet have limitations. Sunwind excludes electronics and wearing parts – these have a two-year guarantee. Incinolet excludes certain parts from the guarantee completely.

Even if the guarantee defect is one that you cannot rectify yourself, you will still have to take the toilet out yourself and drive it to the nearest retailer or service workshop.  That is why it is a good idea to check how far away you are from the nearest reception point before you make the final decision to buy.

Facts about the test

Testfakta Research, on the instructions of Cinderella Eco Solution AS, carried out a comparison laboratory test of electric incinerating toilets. The laboratory tests were performed by RISE (Research Institutes of Sweden) Built Environment Division, Energy and Circular Economy Department.

To read more about how the laboratory test was performed and how the results were evaluated, please click here.

 

 

What is an electric incinerating toilet?

An electric incinerating toilet is a toilet in which urine, faeces and toilet paper are incinerated at high temperature. The incineration process heats the waste to a temperature of 500 – 600 °C. The gases produced are vented through a flue pipe. The oxygen supply for combustion is taken either from the indoor space or direct from outside. A fan is fitted to the toilets to ensure that the flue gases are vented. After the incineration process, the ashes are collected in an incineration chamber (ash pan). Incineration is efficient, and the quantity of ash produced is limited, which means that it will probably not be necessary to empty the ash pan more than once a week in normal use.

 

 

Some things to think about before you buy

Before you buy an incinerating toilet, it is a good idea to think about the level of service you can expect from each make – just in case something goes wrong with the toilet.

There is a massive difference in the number of service centres and where they are located between the different manufacturers. It might be necessary for you to dismantle your toilet and drive a really long distance to the closest service partner.

 

Differences in the coverage and length of the guarantee

The guarantees that manufacturers provide for incinerating toilets vary in length, and it is really worth reading the small print.

Separett’s three-year guarantee does not cover ”normal wear and tear, corrosion or defects in the surface”, and some components have a one-year guarantee. Fritidstoa’s three-year guarantee, however, applies to the whole toilet. The five-year guarantees provided by Sunwind and Incinolet have limitations. Sunwind excludes electronics and wearing parts – these have a two-year guarantee. Incinolet excludes certain parts from the guarantee completely.

Even if the guarantee defect is one that you cannot rectify yourself, you will still have to take the toilet out yourself and drive it to the nearest retailer or service workshop.  That is why it is a good idea to check how far away you are from the nearest reception point before you make the final decision to buy.